Two
recent prosecutions by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) have brought home
the gravity of the reformed and far more stringent health and safety offence
sentencing guidelines which were introduced in February 2016.
The
new guidelines, applying to breaches of health and safety and food safety
guidelines as well as corporate manslaughter, apply to incidents that occurred on
or after 12 March 2015. Now, large companies in England and Wales will face
fines of up to £10 million for the most serious breaches and magistrates’
courts will be able to impose unlimited fines for offences, whereas before they
could only levy fines of up to £20,000.
Laura
Cameron of Pinsent Masons, a well-known law firm, says that the new regime
should act as a stark warning to businesses that there is no margin for error
or failure when it comes to meeting their duties under the regulations.
"Businesses have been
sent a clear message that the regulatory authorities expect health and safety
to remain a key corporate priority... If they are not already doing so,
directors should be pushing health and safety issues to the top of their agenda,"
she said.
Recent Examples of Hefty Fines
In
November 2016, an automotive manufacturing company that produces parts for the
likes of Jaguar Land Rover and Audi was fined after it was reported to the HSE
that six of its employees had sustained back injuries following repeated heavy
lifting. Mahle Powertrain, the company in question, was fined a staggering £183,340
plus costs of £21,277.
In
December 2016, an Ipswich Burger King franchise operated by KFG Quickserve was
fined after a young employee was scalded by hot oil following several breaches
of health and safety legislation. The resulting fine was £166,000 plus £12,000
costs.
Why Businesses Should Take Heed
The
new guidelines for sentencing following health and safety and food safety
breaches and corporate manslaughter require the courts to undertake an initial
assessment of the overall seriousness of the breach in question. They will pose
questions such as whether there was a risk of serious harm, regardless of
whether such harm actually occurred. They will also look at the liability of
the offender and will take into consideration what could have happened, as well
as what actually did happen.
Fines
will be based on a tiered system based on how serious the offence was; the
business size and the turnover of the company. If there are any mitigating
factors such as evidence of a clean health and safety record and measures
having been taken to ensure the incident did not reoccur, then these will be
considered. However, if the offender stood to gain financially or has a track
record of similar offences then these will also be considered.
The
new sentencing guidelines have clearly proved expensive for the two
organisations mentioned. Business owners therefore need to think, can we afford
to breach the rules?
The
importance of site specific risk assessments and adherence to health and safety
guidelines cannot be emphasised enough for businesses of any size. The fines
being levied now could be devastating, so if you don’t already have procedures
in place to ensure a safe working environment for your staff, take those
crucial steps today.