When
a director of a company is facing insolvency, the thought may well occur to
them to that it may be a good idea to sell or transfer company assets as
quickly as possible in order to protect them.
However,
it’s actually a requirement for company directors to maximise creditor returns
during insolvency, and therefore by selling or transferring assets at an
undervalue they could be considered to be carrying out wrongful or fraudulent trading.
Company directors therefore need to be very careful of transactions at
undervalue if they are facing insolvency.
What are Transactions at Undervalue?
A
transaction at undervalue is a transaction which doesn’t reflect the asset’s
true market value. This can be either a sale of an asset or a transfer of
assets. This can be a problem as company directors are required to maximise
their creditors’ returns during insolvency, and as such these transactions can
be seen as fraudulent or wrongful.
During
insolvency, it is the job of insolvency practitioners to closely inspect all
company transactions, and they will highlight any that they feel are
questionable or suspicious. Administrator and liquidators then have the power
to apply for a court order which can reverse any transaction at undervalue and
restore the situation to the state it was at before the transfer or sale took
place.
It’s
not just the most recent transactions that will be inspected, either;
insolvency practitioners may look into a company’s transactions for up to two
years before the point where they went into administration. If they find any
transaction which has a significantly reduced value, or gifts which have been
made without an associated payment, they are duty bound to make a report to the
Secretary of State.
How are Undervalue Transactions Penalised?
Transactions
at undervalue are a breach of the Insolvency Act 1986, meaning that company
directors that undertake this practice could face both financial penalties as
well as the prospect of criminal prosecution. Indeed, company directors can be
held personally liable for some or all of the company’s debts, and may also be
disqualified for up to 15 years if it is believed that they have traded
wrongfully during insolvency.
Following Formal Insolvency Procedures
It’s
therefore extremely important that company directors think very carefully
before they decide to trade at undervalue in order to try to protect company
assets. Creditor interests must always come first, and if you want to avoid any
accusations of transactions at undervalue, it’s important that company
directors follow a formal procedure for selling or transferring assets.
This
process usually requires a board meeting in the first instance where all action
is carefully documented. A RICS qualified surveyor or valuer should be
appointed to make sure that going concern and forced sales values are provided.
Once assets have changed hands, it’s also important to ensure that funds are
banked swiftly and full records retained for several years following the
statutory requirement.
If
you are at all unsure on how these records need to be maintained, consult the
advice of local bookkeepers. They will be able
to ensure that your documentation and paperwork is present and correct.